Methodology

How the Rental Property Analyzer works

The Rental Property Analyzer underwrites one property as a long-term rental, a short-term rental, or both side by side, over a hold period you choose. This page explains how each number is built.

Revenue

Long-term rental: monthly rent plus other income (pet rent, parking, laundry), times 12, minus a vacancy and credit-loss allowance.

Short-term rental: built month by month. Each month's nights booked are that month's occupancy times its days; room revenue is nights times the average daily rate, adjusted by that month's seasonal multiplier. The number of stays is nights divided by the average length of stay, and each stay adds the cleaning fee you charge. The quick-start "average occupancy" field rescales every month by the same factor, so the seasonal shape is kept (no month goes above 100%). An optional cut to projected short-term revenue (lenders often take 20–25%) tests a weaker market; it lowers your revenue, cash flow and verdict, not only the lender's figure.

Operating costs

Revenue and costs grow each year at the rates you set. Costs usually grow faster than rent, especially insurance and taxes.

The key numbers

MeasureHow it's calculated
Net operating income (NOI)Revenue minus operating costs, before the capital reserve, the basis lenders use so cap rates stay comparable to the market
Cap rateYear-one NOI ÷ all-in cost (price, rehab, closing costs and, for short-term rentals, furnishing)
Income covers the loan payments (DSCR, strict)NOI ÷ annual principal and interest. It counts vacancy, management and repairs, so it tells you whether the property pays for itself. Your target is 1.25 by default (an input under "Your targets"); below 1.0 the property can't cover its own mortgage, whatever the target
Lender's view: rent covers the full payment (DSCR, lender-style)Gross rent ÷ PITIA: principal, interest, property tax, insurance, HOA dues and any mortgage insurance. Most DSCR mortgages use this version, and many lenders want 1.20–1.25. It ignores vacancy and running costs, so it reads higher. It's shown for the long-term rental only: for a short-term rental, where cleaning, management and utilities often take half the revenue or more, it would flatter a deal that loses money
Cash flowNOI minus the capital reserve minus loan payments: the cash you actually keep
Cash-on-cash returnYear-one cash flow ÷ cash invested (down payment, closing costs, points, rehab, furnishing)
Break-even occupancyThe occupancy at which cash flow reaches zero, compared with the occupancy you assumed
IRRThe annual return that makes the cash invested, every year's cash flow and the sale proceeds net to zero, shown before and after tax

The loan is amortized month by month, so interest, principal and the remaining balance are exact for every year of the hold, including interest-only loans.

Taxes

Tax handling is simplified: federal only, no mid-month convention, and no net investment income tax.

The exit

At the end of the hold, the property is sold at its appreciated value, or, if you choose, at final-year NOI divided by an exit cap rate. Selling costs and the remaining loan balance are deducted, then the taxes above. The tool also shows the after-tax result of selling in each earlier year.

Verdict, sensitivity and stress tests

The verdict says whether the deal clears your targets, not whether to buy. It checks three targets, which are inputs you can change under "Your targets": coverage (the strict DSCR, at least 1.25 by default), cash-on-cash return (at least 8%), and how far occupancy can fall before the rental stops paying for itself (at least 8 points). All three met: Clears your targets. Short on coverage, cash return or cushion: Marginal. Negative cash flow, coverage under 1.0, or break-even above the occupancy you assumed: Misses your targets. Local short-term rental rules you flag as deal-breakers mark the short-term case Blocked. Sensitivity tables show which inputs move the result most. Stress tests rerun the deal with interest rates up 2 points, revenue down 10%, a demand shock (vacancy to 15% and short-term occupancy down 15 points), operating costs up 20%, and a recession combining softer versions of all of these with no appreciation.

The answer, and how solid it is

The page answers "Is this rental worth buying?" for the stronger strategy: the better verdict, then the higher after-tax return. It gives two views, because a rental can be thin month to month and still build wealth: the monthly cash flow after tax, and the annual return after tax if you sell at the end of the hold, set against the same cash invested instead.

A Robust, Sensitive or Fragile label says how solid the verdict is, using the five stress tests and the rule on how sure is this answer. The short-term ban case is shown in the stress table but not counted, because it changes the strategy rather than the deal. "What would change the answer" moves one input at a time (price, rent or nightly rate, occupancy, vacancy, property tax, insurance, rate, down payment, management) and reports the nearest value where the verdict changes, exact to the dollar or the shown decimal. The price and the down payment are numbers you choose, so they show as drivers but don't count toward the ±10% test; the estimates (rent, occupancy, vacancy, costs, the rate) do.

What would make it work

Price that clears your targets is the highest whole-dollar price at which the deal clears your targets with nothing else changed; closing costs, property tax and the loan follow the price. In the default example that is $224,923 against a $285,000 asking price. The scoreboard also gives the price at which the deal misses your targets ($295,139), so it's clear the asking price still works, only with less room than your targets ask for. The levers below it are grouped as changes to the property (price, rent, costs), the financing (rate, down payment) and the strategy (management, long-term or short-term, hold period). Each "clears your targets on its own at X" is exact at the value printed: one step nearer today's value does not clear. A bigger down payment is shown apart, because it buys coverage with your own cash and can lower your cash-on-cash return. The hold period changes the long-term view, not the verdict, so the page shows the first year in which selling leaves a profit after tax.

What else could you do with this money?

The cash to close is compared with investing it in a stock index fund instead, at a return you can edit (7% a year before tax by default, the same long-run figure our Rent vs Buy and Mortgage Payoff calculators use), over the same hold. The fund's gain is taxed once at your capital gains rate when sold; tax on dividends along the way is not modelled, which flatters the fund slightly. The fair comparison is the annual rate: the fund's after-tax return against the rental's after-tax IRR. The page also gives the fund return at which investing would come out ahead. A rental is also harder to sell and takes your time; the page says so in words rather than scoring it.

A short-term rental risk checklist (primary-residence rules, HOA bans, night caps, permits, pending rules, oversupply, single-season markets) flags regulatory problems that no amount of good arithmetic can fix.

What the model does not cover

The figures the model uses, and when they were last reviewed, are listed on Sources and updates.

Screenshot of the Rental Property Analyzer Try it Rental Property Analyzer Long-term vs short-term rental: cash flow, returns and taxes, side by side. Open the tool →